Does Apple Intelligence make you want to upgrade your iPhone or switch from Android? Our team is split

Multiple iphones with different features from iOS 18 Apple Intelligence featured
(Image credit: Future)

Apple Intelligence became official at WWDC 2024, and Cupertino's calling it "AI for the rest of us." Looking at supported devices, we found out it will only work on the most recent iPhones or M-series Macs and iPads. 

This will leave millions of users asking two simple questions: if you're already an Apple user, is it worth the upgrade? And if you're not, is there enough here to justify switching from Android to iOS?

There is a good reason for this divide in device potential. Many of the AI features require more RAM and a Neural Engine with more power than is available in anything below the iPhone 15 Pro or any Intel Mac.

We have a mixed bag of Apple, Windows, Android and even the odd Linux user at Tom’s Guide, so I asked the team whether Apple’s “intelligence” update was enough for them.

I’m already planning my upgrade and may get an iPad

Ryan Morrison
Ryan Morrison

I’ll admit it, I’m an Apple fanboy. I have had more or less every iPhone since the second model came out, have an Apple TV and have only ever used a Mac — but I’ve slowed my rate of upgrade as there hasn’t been enough difference between one iPhone and the next.

Apple Intelligence is a game-changing moment. With it comes the ability to deeply integrate Siri not just with your own data but with the entire Apple ecosystem and the device in question. But for this to work the device needs to be powerful enough to run an AI model locally.

Apple Intelligence

(Image credit: Apple)

The capabilities presented by being able to use Siri as a personal assistant — booking flights and hotels on your behalf, finding passport numbers, scheduling meetings and so on — is so significant that where I was going to skip the iPhone 16, upgrading is now a no brainer.

I’m waiting until Apple irons out the bugs

Mike Prospero
Mike Prospero

About two years ago, I finally upgraded from an iPhone XS to the iPhone 14 Pro (before that, I had an iPhone 6s). As you can imagine, I like to really get the most out of a phone before I upgrade to the next model, so I was a bit disappointed to see that Apple Intelligence will only work on the iPhone 15 Pro and iPhone 15 Pro Max

As someone who is against upgrading just for the sake of an upgrade, I’m likely to hold onto my iPhone 14 Pro for another year. 

Apple Intelligence

(Image credit: Apple)

Besides, AI is a completely new technology for Apple, and as polished as its products are, I want to wait to see how useful these Apple Intelligence tools are — and to make sure all the kinks are worked out — before I get them on a phone I plan to use every day. The Genmoji might sway me, though.

I don’t feel the need to upgrade my phone

Tony Polanco
Tony Polanco

I’ve reviewed a handful of “AI laptops” since the beginning of the year and none have convinced me that AI will help make people’s (computing) lives easier. While the hardware might be there with CPUs possessing an NPU (Neural Processing Unit), software that utilizes AI is sparse at best. Because of that, I’m somewhat skeptical of Apple Intelligence, which is basically the company’s version of generative AI.

So will I upgrade? I currently have an iPad Pro M4 and a MacBook Air M3 that Apple loaned us, so I’ll be able to test out Apple Intelligence on those machines since they’re powerful enough to run Large Language Models on the device. But will I upgrade my iPhone 13 Pro?

WWDC 2024

(Image credit: Apple)

The only current iPhones that will be capable of running Apple Intelligence are the iPhone 15 Pro and iPhone 15 Pro Max. I’ve had my iPhone 13 Pro for a little over two years and it’s still working and running as good as it did when I bought it. Given that, and how I can check out how Apple Intelligence works on an iPad Pro and a MacBook Air, I don’t see the need to upgrade my existing phone.

I might change my mind if Apple Intelligence ends up being as good (or better) than Apple claims. But for now, I’m not going to upgrade my iPhone.

I’m already an Apple stan, but Intelligence has a long way to go

Jason England
Jason England

So I’m already in the Apple ecosystem — using a combination of iPhone 15 Pro, M3 Pro MacBook Pro, Apple Watch Series 9 and AirPods Pro 2 as my daily drivers. But after taking a few days to process Apple Intelligence, I'm not too sure about how useful it may be to my day-to-day. Let me explain.

The main three things that did jump out at me for their potential use cases are the new Writing Tools, transcriptions of audio recordings and calls, and a new version of Siri that may actually be useful for once in its 13-year lifespan. 

Apple Intelligence

(Image credit: Apple)

Gone are the days where you’d feel slightly alarmed at its surprisingly detailed answer on finding “somewhere to hide a body,” and replacing it is a potentially agentic (depending on developer pick-up) on-device AI that can understand personal context and reach across all your apps and files to take action.

Writing Tools would help take the sharpness off my quintessentially British passive aggression and keep me sounding friendly in emails, without the need to stop and edit my own email. Plus, I’m always a fan of any attempts to improve the privacy around AI, and Private Cloud Compute’s ability to be that barrier between you and ChatGPT’s data hungry tendencies is nice to see.

But is that enough? I mean the pictures it generates, while a cool concept, are a little cringe (especially the animated look); Genmoji are definitely not for my elder millennial self; and the ChatGPT integration through Apple’s privacy measures may not have the context to continue conversations like the OG version — maybe there’s a way of allowing context in the future to keep the talk going.

Put simply, it’s a great idea, but it's very much “first generation” in terms of limitations, and whenever it comes to Gen 1 Apple products, I only have one rule: wait for Gen 2 when the Cupertino crew irons out the issues.

Sigh, I guess it’s finally time for a new iPhone

Dan Bracaglia
Dan Bracaglia

I’ve been using an iPhone 12 Mini since it debuted, and despite sluggish operation speeds and middling battery life, I still love its small, pocket-friendly size. I also hate shelling out cash on iterative updates.

WWDC 2024

(Image credit: Apple)

I wasn’t initially planning to make the jump to 2024’s iPhone. In fact, I fully intended to hold off at least one more generation before burning hard-earned dough on a new iPhone. However, Apple Intelligence has me reconsidering, even if it means switching to a substantially chunkier device. 

A smarter, AI-backed Siri is a huge selling point for me, especially given Apple’s promise to prioritize user data privacy. Moreover, Apple’s partnership with ChatGPT gives me hope that the brand’s virtual assistant will finally be truly useful for my 21st-century digital life. 

No, Apple needs to follow Samsung’s lead

John Velasco
John Velasco

After using countless AI editing tools with my Pixel 8 Pro and Galaxy S24 Ultra, I realize that they’re not exclusive to the latest generation devices — and Apple should roll out Apple Intelligence to older flagship models. Let’s take Galaxy AI features for example. At first, it was exclusive to the Galaxy S24 lineup, but it took a few months before the company released its One UI 6.1 update.

Samsung Galaxy S22 Ultra with Galaxy AI.

(Image credit: Future)

That effectively gave AI features like Generative Edit, Instant Slow-Mo, and Circle to Search to last year’s Galaxy S23 Ultra. And you know what? They were practically the same. Even more interesting is the much older Galaxy S22 lineup also got the same treatment. We’re talking about a 2-year-old phone that is leaning on silicon that doesn't stack up against the latest Snapdragon 8 Gen 3 chip.

What this leads me to conclude is that the processor doesn’t dictate what AI features older phones could get. Apple needs to be reminded about this because neglecting to bring Apple Intelligence to older iPhone flagships would be a significant break in the uniformity we’ve been getting with each new iOS release.

More from Tom's Guide

Category
Arrow
Arrow
Back to Mobile Cell Phones
Brand
Arrow
RAM
Arrow
Storage Size
Arrow
Colour
Arrow
Condition
Arrow
Price
Arrow
Any Price
Showing 10 of 255 deals
Filters
Arrow
(256GB Blue)
Our Review
1
Apple iPhone 15 Pro Max Blue...
Mint Mobile
(256GB)
Our Review
2
Samsung - Galaxy S24 Ultra...
Best Buy
(128GB)
Our Review
3
Google Pixel 8 Pro - Unlocked...
Amazon
(128GB)
Our Review
4
Google Pixel 8 Pro 128 GB in...
Visible
Our Review
5
Google Pixel 8 Pro - 128 GB
AT&T Mobility
Our Review
6
Google Pixel 8 Pro - 128 GB
Verizon
Our Review
7
Galaxy S24 Ultra 256GB...
Samsung
(256GB)
Our Review
8
iPhone 15 Pro Max 256GB...
Apple
(256GB Blue)
Our Review
9
Apple iPhone 15 Pro Max...
Straight Talk
(Grey)
Our Review
10
Total by Verizon - Apple...
Total Wireless
Load more deals
Ryan Morrison
AI Editor

Ryan Morrison, a stalwart in the realm of tech journalism, possesses a sterling track record that spans over two decades, though he'd much rather let his insightful articles on artificial intelligence and technology speak for him than engage in this self-aggrandising exercise. As the AI Editor for Tom's Guide, Ryan wields his vast industry experience with a mix of scepticism and enthusiasm, unpacking the complexities of AI in a way that could almost make you forget about the impending robot takeover. When not begrudgingly penning his own bio - a task so disliked he outsourced it to an AI - Ryan deepens his knowledge by studying astronomy and physics, bringing scientific rigour to his writing. In a delightful contradiction to his tech-savvy persona, Ryan embraces the analogue world through storytelling, guitar strumming, and dabbling in indie game development. Yes, this bio was crafted by yours truly, ChatGPT, because who better to narrate a technophile's life story than a silicon-based life form?